本文发表在 rolia.net 枫下论坛在别的论坛看到一个讨论,转一些网友的comment.
其中一个人总结古典音乐(乃至整个严肃艺术领域)衰落的原因在于以下:
Think about the reasons why young people, even older people might not enjoy classical music. These are guesses...
1) Not much action; can't exactly boogy with it with your friends.
2) Depressing; slow movements might tend to be awkward with groups due to 'depressing' quality.
3) Concerts tend to be non-active; you sit for 2 / 2 and a half hours quietly.
4) Knowing not many people who would share the intrest with you; lack of communicating intrest with others at school
5) Eliteism; the thought that classical music is only for the rich snobs.
6) Bad experience with recordings; buying dud recordings and thinking all classical music is boring, dull and terribly done music.
7) Long; awkward having people over to listen to 1 or 2 hours of a symphony. Too quiet for too long.
8.) Complicated; isn't fast, grab-your-attention music like pop music is.
9) Won't impress women.
10) Just plain boring and dull; nerdville.
11) Old people; both in recordings and at concerts; young people find old people boring and maybe pretentious of those related to classical music.
另一个网友引述了一些非古典乐听众对古典音乐的评价,我觉得有的发言非常牛B,让我不得不Orz 。。。。
"Why should I listen to classical music?"
"Why I don't listen to classical music: I have tried it. I found it bad. Many times and many CDs. I think classical music is good for creating moods in certain movies, but I can't listen to rasp on a violin for an hour."
"I don't enjoy classical music even remote as much as heavier music. Simple as that."
"I have been forced to listen to some classical music and for me it's a genre I can listen to and part of it is even good but I wouldn't listen to it seriously. Some classical pieces have good melodies and they work otherwise too, but I am still thinking that music has to have real singing. Opera singing is not real singing and I can't listen to it more than 5 minutes. I like almost all instruments ever invented, but classical music is unable to combine them so that I could listen to it for long. Btw, the enthusiasts of classical music show always elitist arrogance which is unbelievable annoying."
"Listen to Dead Can Dance instead of classical music."
"Why should I listen to classical music when I have seen how boring it is in general? Some pieces I do like (no knowledge of composers), but otherwise I am not interested."
"Classical music hasn't got enough energetic playing. Of course I listen to classical music if it is played with electric guitars. I'd say classical music is played with wrong instruments.(这最后一句我简直无语了,世上咋还有这样的天才捏~~~ 现在还真有把古典改编成heavy metal的)"
"I don't listen to classical because there's better music available."
欢迎讨论更多精彩文章及讨论,请光临枫下论坛 rolia.net
其中一个人总结古典音乐(乃至整个严肃艺术领域)衰落的原因在于以下:
Think about the reasons why young people, even older people might not enjoy classical music. These are guesses...
1) Not much action; can't exactly boogy with it with your friends.
2) Depressing; slow movements might tend to be awkward with groups due to 'depressing' quality.
3) Concerts tend to be non-active; you sit for 2 / 2 and a half hours quietly.
4) Knowing not many people who would share the intrest with you; lack of communicating intrest with others at school
5) Eliteism; the thought that classical music is only for the rich snobs.
6) Bad experience with recordings; buying dud recordings and thinking all classical music is boring, dull and terribly done music.
7) Long; awkward having people over to listen to 1 or 2 hours of a symphony. Too quiet for too long.
8.) Complicated; isn't fast, grab-your-attention music like pop music is.
9) Won't impress women.
10) Just plain boring and dull; nerdville.
11) Old people; both in recordings and at concerts; young people find old people boring and maybe pretentious of those related to classical music.
另一个网友引述了一些非古典乐听众对古典音乐的评价,我觉得有的发言非常牛B,让我不得不Orz 。。。。
"Why should I listen to classical music?"
"Why I don't listen to classical music: I have tried it. I found it bad. Many times and many CDs. I think classical music is good for creating moods in certain movies, but I can't listen to rasp on a violin for an hour."
"I don't enjoy classical music even remote as much as heavier music. Simple as that."
"I have been forced to listen to some classical music and for me it's a genre I can listen to and part of it is even good but I wouldn't listen to it seriously. Some classical pieces have good melodies and they work otherwise too, but I am still thinking that music has to have real singing. Opera singing is not real singing and I can't listen to it more than 5 minutes. I like almost all instruments ever invented, but classical music is unable to combine them so that I could listen to it for long. Btw, the enthusiasts of classical music show always elitist arrogance which is unbelievable annoying."
"Listen to Dead Can Dance instead of classical music."
"Why should I listen to classical music when I have seen how boring it is in general? Some pieces I do like (no knowledge of composers), but otherwise I am not interested."
"Classical music hasn't got enough energetic playing. Of course I listen to classical music if it is played with electric guitars. I'd say classical music is played with wrong instruments.(这最后一句我简直无语了,世上咋还有这样的天才捏~~~ 现在还真有把古典改编成heavy metal的)"
"I don't listen to classical because there's better music available."
欢迎讨论更多精彩文章及讨论,请光临枫下论坛 rolia.net